In Good Company is a home base for daters. A soft place to land for the big-hearted and curious. A playground for your brave, tender inner child. A pit crew for those putting real effort into love. And most of all, we lead with kindness—especially when modern dating forgets how.
The Matchmaking Journey
Matchmaking with us is not about buying dates. It’s about stepping into a season of being deeply seen, supported, and championed in your search for love.
We begin by listening. Really listening — to your story, your values, your quirks, the shape of the life you’ve built and the one you’re still dreaming of. We want to understand not just what you’re looking for, but why it matters to you. This is the ground we’ll stand on together.
From there, we put our creativity, connections, and care to work for you. We scout both within our private database and far beyond it, drawing from the many circles we move through in Central Ohio and across the country. Our eyes are always open on your behalf, looking for the introductions with the highest chance of sparking something real.
When we introduce you to someone, it isn’t random. It’s intentional, thoughtful, curated with you in mind. Each meeting is an opportunity to unfold with curiosity rather than pressure. And after every date, we sit with you in reflection. We talk through what felt good, what didn’t, and what it tells us about where your heart wants to go next. When it’s available, we’ll even bring in gentle reflections from your date, helping you see yourself more clearly through another’s eyes.
This journey is not only about who you meet, but about who you become. Along the way, we’ll offer coaching, encouragement, and creative support — whether that’s refining your profile, refreshing your wardrobe, or helping plan a date that feels just right. We’re in your corner the whole way, your pit crew for love.
The investment starts at $3,000 per month with a three-month minimum. What you’re paying for is not just introductions, but time saved, stress lifted, and the profound relief of not having to do this alone. You’ll have a team dedicated to your love life — people who believe in you, who are resourceful and relentless in their search, who will hold the hope and keep the light on with you.
This is bespoke matchmaking for the big-hearted, the brave, and the growth-minded. It’s for those who know that love is worth the effort, and who are ready to welcome a relationship that feels aligned, alive, and deeply mutual.
Exclusive support for the ones who love differently.
At In Good Company, matchmaking is not a one-size-fits-all service. We’ve designed tiers of support that reflect different levels of care, creativity, and depth of engagement — while always staying true to our values of kindness, curiosity, and intentional connection.
FOUNDATIONS
A steady start to dating with intention
Investment: $3,000/month (3-month minimum)
15-minute clarity consultation to understand your story and what you’re seeking.
We conduct outreach & phone consultations with up to 3 potential matches per week.
Only true matches are presented — saving you time and energy.
Dates are coordinated on your behalf.
Photos are kept confidential at this tier.
PREMIUM
Deeper support and feedback along the way
Investment: $3,750/month (3-month minimum)
30-minute video consultation to get to know you in depth.
Outreach & video consultations with up to 6 potential matches per week.
Matches are vetted, with background checks included.
Dates fully coordinated for you — no more wasted time on “bad dates.”
Post-date feedback loops: we check in with you (and, when possible, your date) to fine tune the process.
Gentle, ongoing dating coaching woven in — helping you reflect, grow, and stay grounded.
Access to our extended matchmaking network & creative outreach efforts.
VIP BESPOKE
White-glove matchmaking for the discerning and deeply ready
Starting at $25,000+ (by invitation only)
This is our most immersive offering, reserved for those who want an all-in, highly personalized journey. It includes:
A deeply collaborative intake and discovery process.
Full access to our extended networks across the country.
Highly discreet, invitation-only introductions.
Hands-on support in crafting your presence (from wardrobe refreshes to profile storytelling).
Surprise, delight, and creative touches woven into your dating experience.
A true “pit crew” for love — guiding you every step of the way.
Want exclusive support from Rachel and the team but not sure where to begin?
LOVE STRATEGY SESSION
Personalized clarity for your next chapter
$400
A 60-minute consultation where we map your dating landscape, identify patterns, and create a plan that feels aligned and hopeful. Plus, Rachel keeps you top of mind when matchmaking for clients.
Enter The Orbit
Step into our private rolodex of singles—it’s free to create your profile, and it’s the first place we look when scouting matches for our clients. The more we know you, the more magic we can make. If someone aligned comes along, we’ll reach out.